Should I Reply to Old Reviews I Never Answered?
Last updated: November 11, 2026
Yes. A late reply still shows the next customer that you pay attention, and the person who wrote the review gets notified. Start with the bad reviews, newest first, then thank the good ones. You don't need to answer every review from five years ago in one sitting.
Catch up in this order
- Bad reviews from the last year. These are what the next customer reads first.
- Bad reviews that are older but still near the top.
- Good reviews from the last year.
- Everything older, a few at a time.
Keep old replies short and current
For a bad review that's two years old, say thanks, say what changed and invite them to reach out. For example: "Thanks for this, Dave. We changed how we schedule since then, so you get a time window the day before. If you ever need us again, ask for the office manager."
Here's the thing. Don't argue about what happened two years ago. The reply is for the next customer reading it, not to win the old fight.
Should I apologize for the late reply?
A short "sorry for the slow reply" is fine on a bad review. On good ones, skip it and just thank them.
The customer might update their review
Google says the person who wrote the review is notified when you reply, and they can still change their review after reading it (Manage customer reviews). Some won't, and that's fine. You're replying for the next customer either way.
Then don't fall behind again
Set review alerts and give one person the job. We wrote how in how fast should I reply to a new Google review. Keep asking every customer for a review after every job, so new replies push the old ones down. Reviews are part of our local SEO work.
Questions you should also be asking
- How fast should I reply to a new Google review?
- Should I reply to every Google review, even the good ones?
- How do I reply to a bad Google review?
- Should I reply to reviews on other sites besides Google?
- Is it OK to use AI to write our review replies?
FAQ
Is it too late to reply to a review from years ago?
No. A late reply still shows the next customer you care. Start with the bad ones.
Will the customer see my reply to an old review?
Google says the person who wrote the review is notified when you reply.
Should I reply to old reviews with no text, just stars?
If you have time, a short thank you is fine. Do the written reviews first.
How many old reviews should I reply to a day?
As many as you can do well. A few good replies a day beats copying the same line onto fifty.
Can I edit an old reply I already posted?
Yes. You can edit or delete your reply from your Business Profile.
Want us to catch up on your old reviews and set up a reply habit that sticks? and we'll go through it with you.