Someone Left Bad Reviews and Wants Money to Remove Them. What Do We Do?
Last updated: November 19, 2026
Don't pay them and don't reply to the demand. Google has its own form for reporting review extortion, so save every message and report it there. Then keep asking every customer for a review, so real ones keep coming in while Google looks into it.
What this scam looks like
Google calls review extortion a serious policy violation. It says these scams often start with a sudden wave of 1 star and 2 star reviews, then someone asks for money, goods or services to take them down (Google's help page).
For example, a dental office in Etobicoke wakes up to six 1 star reviews from people who were never patients. The next day a message comes in offering to "clean up" the profile for a fee.
Why paying makes it worse
Google says not to engage with these people or pay them, because it can encourage more attempts and paying doesn't mean the reviews come down (Google's help page). And once they know you pay, they'll be back.
What to do today
- Don't reply to the demand and don't bargain. Google says not to try to sort it out yourself by offering money or services.
- Save the proof now. Screenshots of every message with the date, time and the sender's details, plus a link to each fake review. Google asks for all of it.
- Write down two dates: when the bad reviews started and when the demand came in.
- Report it on Google's extortion form. It's linked from Google's help page. Google says its team investigates and tells you the result.
- Keep asking every customer for a review. Real, recent reviews push the fake ones down. Here's how to ask every customer for a Google review without being awkward.
Should we reply to the fake reviews?
You can, once, calmly, from the business. Something like "We have no record of this visit and we've reported it to Google." Don't mention the money and don't argue. Dental and health offices: never confirm or deny that someone is a patient. More in how do I reply to a bad Google review?
Extortion or just a bad review?
Google says the extortion form is only for cases where someone demanded money or favours to remove reviews. Spam or off topic reviews with no demand go through the normal report (Google's help page). And if someone offers to delete your bad reviews for a fee with no threat attached, that's a different problem. We covered it in someone offered to delete your bad reviews.
Reviews are what keep your phone ringing from Google Maps, so we watch them closely in our local SEO work.
Questions you should also be asking
- Someone offered to delete your bad reviews. Don't pay them yet.
- How do I reply to a bad Google review?
- Why does Google keep removing my real reviews?
- How do I ask every customer for a Google review without being awkward?
- How long does Google take to look at a review extortion report?
- What if the fake reviews come back after Google removes them?
FAQ
Should we pay to get the reviews taken down?
No. Google says paying can encourage more attempts and doesn't mean the reviews will be removed.
How do we report review extortion to Google?
Use Google's merchant extortion report form, linked from its help page on extortion scams. Attach your screenshots and links to the reviews.
Should we reply to the person asking for money?
No. Google says not to engage with them. Save the messages and report them.
Will the fake reviews hurt us while we wait?
They can. That's why you keep asking every customer for a review, so the real ones keep coming in.
Dealing with a wave of fake reviews in Toronto? and we'll look at your profile with you.